• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Her Loyal Sons

A Notre Dame Football Blog

  • Home
  • Discord
  • ND Bowl Tie-Ins
  • Merch
  • Extra Life
  • Navigation Menu: Social Icons

    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • YouTube
    • RSS
Home > Notre Dame Football > This Is Not The End For Brian Kelly

This Is Not The End For Brian Kelly

September 7, 2016 by Fresno Domer

via @LTorbin

via @LTorbin

The Irish got in a shootout Sunday night in Austin and lost in double overtime.

It happens. This is not the beginning of the end. 

That’s not to gloss over some pretty poor coaching decisions: rotating QBs didn’t work––to put it mildly––the key 3rd and 12 play call, the wasted challenge on an obviously dropped INT; those are the ones the come to mind offhand, but there are probably others (We’ll save BVG, the defense, and the targeting non-call for  another day). Kelly had a bad night. That happens too.

As I wrote about in the Texas scouting report, the Longhorns are a very talented team. Talented enough to beat Notre Dame. They proved that on the field Sunday night. Shane Buechele paired with Sterlin Gilbert and a talented, if inconsistent, O-line are going to win a lot of games in the coming years. The skill position players are there too: Foreman and Burt have legitimate game-breaking ability.  

But any notion that the best of Brian Kelly’s Notre Dame teams are already history is ignoring the substantial evidence that Notre Dame is functioning at highest level since the Holtz era. The Irish recruiting classes for 2017 (6th) and 2018 (2nd) are shaping up to be historically good. Kelly’s teams are winning games at a 69.6% clip. That substantially higher than Charlie Weis (56.5%), Ty Willingham (58.3%) or Bob Davie (58.3%). And, not insignificantly, Kelly has coached Notre Dame to a National Championship game in his tenure.

This isn’t late era Mark Richt at Georgia; this is a program in its prime. Kelly has Notre Dame performing at a very high level while playing a national schedule, with rigorous admissions and academic standards. The depth chart is improving year-over-year, and as of late, the Irish are only losing to really good teams –– which is what I think this year’s Texas team will be in the final accounting.

If we use the Holtz era teams as the benchmark for Notre Dame’s success, Kelly’s teams are underperforming by about 5% in terms of win percentage. If however, you adjust for the significant changes in the college football landscape since the late ‘80’s, a semi-Independent, top-rated academic school wanting to graduate players, with a very limited natural recruiting base, winning basically 70% of it’s games is probably as good as it’s going to get for Notre Dame.

That might be hard for people who envision an Alabama type run of dominance in the future, but that’s message board fodder anyhow. Just remember, Notre Dame had a 3 win season within the decade.

  • Author
  • Recent Posts
Fresno Domer
Latest posts by Fresno Domer (see all)
  • This Is Not The End For Brian Kelly - September 7, 2016
  • Scouting Report: Texas - September 2, 2016
  • Scouting Report: Stanford - August 2, 2016

Share this:

  • Tweet
  • Email

Filed Under: Notre Dame Football Tagged With: Brian Kelly

About Fresno Domer

Previous Post: « Texas Loss Marks Beginning of Kelly’s End At ND
Next Post: Morning Roundup: Sept. 7, 2016 »

Primary Sidebar

Latest Podcast

Click here to support the pod!

Recent Posts

The Cowboy Beebop "See You Space Cowboy" ending title frame with the HLS logo.

Epilogue

HLS Podcast Finale

Manti Te'o Faux Cover

The Final Fiesta: Notre Dame vs Oklahoma State NCAA ’14 Sim

Penultimate Picks Pod

2021 Bowl Picks: Week 2

Copyright © 2023 · Foodie Pro & The Genesis Framework · Login

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.