If you went to Mass on Sunday morning, or received and read your FaithND daily e-mail, you know that the Gospel reading was one about humility. Jesus instructs us, among other things, to not fall for the long tassels and wide phylacteries that all the cool kids are wearing. But why the heck should we be poor-mouthing Saturday’s 48-37 win over Wake Forest?
It is more than fair to say that The Irish D was “off” on Saturday and especially in the game’s second-half. Whether you chalk that up to the weather or to Wake’s familiarity with Mike Elko’s defensive scheme and tendancies or to players not playing well, you’re not wrong. Notre Dame had a tough time handling the elements, the elements of defense, and the experience Wake’s quarterback displayed.
But if you’re unhappy with where this team is, you should really develop a new way to pass a Saturday afternoon or evening. I recommend strategy games or model building. If you can’t deal with an eleven point win over a solid team, I don’t see how you’ve managed lo these many years.
On the heels of what was admittedly our “worst” win of the season, The Irish are up two spots in the AP Poll and three (!) in the Coaches’ Poll. When the CFP Rankings come out, they should remain in third place. They shouldn’t move up, since the air is pretty rare in third and because both Georgia and Alabama won. Clemson (#4) survived against NC State, Oklahoma (#5) won ugly over Oklahoma State and gave up 52 (!) points, and tOSU (#6) and PSU (#7) lost.
The Irish didn’t just win by eleven points on Saturday. They won by eleven points mostly without Josh Adams. They won by eleven points mostly without Josh Adams and with Ian Book under center for a good number of snaps. Notre Dame heads into the Miami (Florida) game with the nation’s seventh-best scoring offence and fifth-best rushing offense. The Irish are approximately five hundred and two hundred yards ahead of where they FINISHED in 2012 and 2015, respectively.
Notre Dame started on the inside, looking out, of the College Football Playoff matrix. The debate about The Irish is whether they fall out, not if a late season win is good enough to get them in. This is a nice place to be in November.
Winning by eleven in bad weather is another sign that this Notre Dame team is different, and better, than teams past. Sure, the weather on Saturday wasn’t as bad as it was last year against NC State or in 2015 against Clemson. But it wasn’t good weather, either, and the outcome on the field was never in doubt.
You do remember 2012, don’t you? The Irish went undefeated, which I am certain you remember. But how many of those wins could have just as easily been losses? How many of Notre Dame’s wins this year could have been losses? None of them. You can’t point to a play or a drive where the game could have turned on the outcome. 2017 Notre Dame is beating teams, sure, but they’re also denying them the chance to win.
Heading into Miami, you, the fan, should not be over-confident. But you can take off your sackcloth and put on a 33 Trucking hat and cheer.
- Finding Flaws in a Diamond: Clemson’s Rushing Offense - December 17, 2018
- Why Nobody Will Cotton to Notre Dame - December 3, 2018
- Irish Finish Regular Season Perfect 12-0 - November 26, 2018

Exactly!!! I think they also said it was Wolford’s 41st start for Wake too?! He’s been around the block; I remember watching him in 2015. They ran a lot of play action and quick passes. The Irish will get after Rozier! Wimbush is also a baller. Glad he was able to return to action. AND Book looked solid too. Loved the play action call from the one before halftime. Only shame was Adams going down because I think he would have had a huge day BUT we will need him for these final games so perhaps rest was the best thing for him! GO IRISH!!!!
Hey thanks for reading and for commenting! Go Irish!
Bayou Irish,
Do NOT tell me how I should watch the Irish! I have been an avid ND fan for more than 40 years and I played Division I football myself. First off, stop using the weather conditions to justify ND’s poor performance on defense. Wake Forest played in the same conditions and moved the ball all over the Irish and put up 587 yds of total offense. Just the week before, the ND defense totally shut down the NC State QB (Finley) that hadn’t thrown an interception in well over 300 passes. The Irish defense had him so flustered that it seemed he didn’t even want to be on the field in the 2nd half. Not so with Wolford and Wake. Heck, he might even have name thrown in the Heisman conversation after that performance. Ok, a bit of an overstatement!
So far this year, I have heard Brian Kelly say that the Irish mindset each and every game has been one simple thing … DOMINATE THE OPPONENT!!! It was clear, when the Irish were on defense, that Wake Forest was much more prepared for Mike Elko and the Irish defense, than the Irish defense and Mike Elko were prepared for the Wake offense. Yes, Wake had a strong familiarity with Mike Elko and how he coaches defense, but the same is true for Mike Elko knowing how Wake coaches offense. Wake’s success against the Irish D was far better than what the Irish D had against the Wake offense. On 4 straight Wake possessions, ND was only rushing 2 players, with #41 just standing there in the middle. It was obvious that his responsibility was to key on Wolford and tackle him if he too off running. Even when Wolford did take off, he ran right by #41 and picked up even more yards. That said, it is very clear that ND was not DOMINATING THE OPPONENT up front on defense. Not only that, if we are only rushing 2, and #41 standing there reading the QB, then we had 8 men in the secondary playing the pass and Wake still had receivers getting wide open. If our strategy and mindset is DOMINATE THE OPPONENT, and we are NOT dominating up front or on the back end, how is that a winning defensive strategy??? I am bringing up those 4 possessions for 2 reasons – it was NOT dominating the opponent and Wake scored TDs on every one of those 4 possessions that we played SOFT defense!!!
One last point! Despite the fact our O-line helped us rack up 380 rushing (or something like that), we got stopped on a 4th and 2 and a few other short yardage situations. That may not seem like a significant issue, but I keep hearing how ND might very well have the best O-line in the country, the way we have been racking up the rushing yards. If that is true, why are we getting stopped by Wake when the O-line should be coming off the ball and moving the entire D-line??? I played O-line myself, so I know what is supposed to happen. The ND O-line either opens up a huge hole for Josh or Brandon or anyone else, or they get a bunch of stalemates and no movement of the line of scrimmage. I know this because when I watch a game, I watch the line of scrimmage.
Yes, I realize there is a marked difference in how this team is playing, compared to the 4-8 team of last year, but this team could be SO much better!!!