From time to time, HLS will have a guest post from a contributor whom we will dub “The Ref”. Think of it as the Mike Pereira of HLS.
Without further ado, I give you our first offering from “The Ref”:
Greetings to my friends, fellow Blue and Gold fanatics, and to the gracious purveyors of the HLS universe! I am “The Ref†and the final installment of the exhaustingly underwhelming nation-wide search for new HLS blogging talent. You know a talent search is at its absolute last strings when it invites a football official, the most hated and vile scum of the earth to join its ranks. However, that is where we currently stand.
My goal for this space is to help clarify, educate, and assuage the concerns of the ND faithful with regards to rules interpretations, specific play scenarios, and any questions you may have regarding the philosophy of the game of football. So to help in that end, I would like to begin by offering my credentials. First of all, yes I really AM a football official. My HLS handle is a bit of a misnomer because I am NOT a referee (I can actually move on the field and I know what I’m doing out there). I am what is referred to in officiating circles as a Wing Official. Primarily a Line Judge, but I also work a number of games as the Head Linesman. I am also a Back Judge on occasion. I live in the great football state of TEXAS(!!!) and as such I am fairly well-versed in the NCAA rules. In addition to the colleges we service here in the state, our high schools also follow the NCAA rulebook unlike 48 other states that use the National Federation rulebook (Massachusetts also uses NCAA).
We have a lot of ground to cover because there are some fairly significant changes this year. We will tackle these a few at a time. I will begin this series by examining the Blocking Below the Waist (BBW) changes.
Here is a list of the rules changes for this year regarding BBW:
Before I list the rule changes, I need to bring up the change to this rule LAST year because of the cascading effect that had to the changes this year. Before 2011, blocking below the waist was a legal act and restricted in certain situations. They changed the philosophy making BBW ILLEGAL except for specific situations. This is very important because in the situations where an official questions is a block is a foul, before 2011, it usually would be allowed and is now usually flagged.
- Before a change of possession, no offensive player may block towards his own goal line if they are beyond the line of scrimmage. Rule 9-1-6a
- Restricted Players:
- Linemen who are more than 7-yards from the center
- A back who’s whole frame is outside the tackle box (5-yards from the center) or outside the frame of the second lineman from the center in either direction
- A back who was outside the tackle box and is in motion (usually receivers, TEs)
- Restricted players cannot block below the waist against defense players who are inside the tackle box area. Restricted players CAN block below the waist toward their adjacent sideline or along the North-South line (which is really just the North line now).
- Before a change of possession, defense players can ONLY BBW within 5-yards of the LOS anywhere between the sidelines
- Defense may not BBW against receivers attempting to catch a backwards pass.
- Defense may not BBW against receivers beyond the NZ unless they are trying to get to the ball or the ball carrier until a legal forward pass occurs. After the pass, BBW is legal.
- Adjacent sideline is the players “outside†sideline or the sideline to which he is moving towards.
Blocking below the waist, now, here is the real doozie of a rule change. Not many people are aware, but the BIG change in this rule happened last year. See my editorial note above about the big shift in philosophy. I guess the first thing to say about the BBW rules this year is that it was pretty much expected, we just weren’t sure how far it would go. Dr. Rogers Redding is the Secretary and Rules Editor of the NCAA. He has hinted for a number of years now that BBW will eventually become totally illegal. Federation rules is this way, the NCAA is heading in that direction. The reason is player safety. There is probably no more dangerous way to lose an entire season than to be blocked at your waist or below from a side or from behind. This action is blowing out knees, breaking legs, destroying ankles. This rule change goes along with a major point of emphasis in the rulebook last year on watching out for chop blocks (Hi-low combination).
Here is a video of a scenario that illustrates what is being addressed (illegal):
So what did they change last year other than philosophy? Well for one, they took out the restriction on blocking low beyond 15 yards. They exchanged this with a new restriction disallowing blocks back towards the inside of the field. They invented a new concept called the North-South line. This year, that term effectively has become the North line because in no circumstance can a player block low back towards his goal line.
Also, the rule more clearly explained who in the backfield was restricted. As an official, this rule is one of the hardest ones to officiate. Typically, it is the R’s job to watch players coming out of the backfield for this rule. All last season, every chapter and conference had confusion about who was restricted in the backfield. If they went in motion, were they allowed to block low or not? This year, Dr. Redding makes it more clear. If your body is COMPLETELY outside the tackle box (5-yards from center) or outside the second lineman from the C, you are restricted. Also, if you start outside of the tackle box and go in MOTION, you are restricted.
Here is a video to illustrate (legal):
The common objection to this change is similar to the kickoffs being moved to the 35 that “football is about pounding your opponent and if they get hurt, so be it.†My response is we need to be in the business of playing football, not destroying careers. The rules committee, which is primarily comprised of head coaches holds this view and will lead to better games for all of us. No one wants to see their best players knocked out of games unnecessarily. Yes, injuries will and do happen, but I think the committee is doing a great job at mitigating those.
Thanks for reading and remember, if you have any questions during the year and would like me to address a play or two, post on the Sideline Forum and I will select a few of them to write about. Next week, I will dive into the kickoff and helmet changes.
–The Ref
- Epilogue - January 3, 2022
- HLS Podcast Finale - January 2, 2022
- The Final Fiesta: Notre Dame vs Oklahoma State NCAA ’14 Sim - December 31, 2021
Welcome to HLS! Pretty excited for these posts…I tend to be super-analytical about the game, so I love these insights.
MA playing under NCAA rules is a joke. They also play 10-11 minute quarters, yet still pay officials more than anywhere else I’ve seen. No wonder they crown 19 ‘state champions’.
/rant. Great addition!
There are some good officials i know from around there. They posted some good vids from last year’s state playoffs. I remember your state had a lot of trouble last year with the unsportsmanlike conduct enforced as
A live ball foul last yr. I think the
Majority of those vids we used as training came from the MA playoffs
Good officials, certainly. I think they definitely benefit from having a great pipeline to working the many D2/3 colleges throughout the region.
As for the infamous live ball unsportsmanlike, that episode really encapsulates a lot of things wrong with Boston/Massachusetts. The MIAA issued a milquetoast letter ‘supporting’ the call, and then the mayor of Boston treated the losing team to lunch. Pretty shameful all around. How was the call discussed in your association?
I think this is the play you’re referring to:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bP_mCEP-1z0
We had about 10 pages of commentary on this situation and pretty much everyone agreed that it was a bad call. The rule for UC states that you cannot:
1. No player, substitute, coach or other person subject to the rules shall
use abusive, threatening or obscene language or gestures, or engage in
such acts that provoke ill will or are demeaning to an opponent, to game
officials or to the image of the game, including but not limited to:
(a) Pointing the finger(s), hand(s), arm(s) or ball at an opponent, or
imitating the slashing of the throat.
(b) Taunting, baiting or ridiculing an opponent verbally.
(c) Inciting an opponent or spectators in any other way, such as
simulating the firing of a weapon or placing a hand by the ear to
request recognition.
(d) Any delayed, excessive, prolonged or choreographed act by which
a player (or players) attempts to focus attention upon himself (or
themselves).
(e) An unopposed ball carrier obviously altering stride as he approaches
the opponent’s goal line or diving into the end zone.
(f) Removal of a player’s helmet before he is in the team area
(Exceptions: Team, media or injury timeouts; equipment adjustment;
through play; between periods; and during a measurement for a first
down).
(g) Punching one’s own chest or crossing one’s arms in front of the chest
while standing over a prone player.
(h) Going into the stands to interact with spectators, or bowing at the
waist after a good play.
I heard that the call was made because of an altered stride that began at the 9-yd line, but based on that video, I just dont see it. I think this may have been a problem with how MA schedules officials for the playoffs, instead of sending a full crew or even half-crews to the game, they make up an entire crew from officials all over the state.This causes a number of problems for us because we’ve never worked with each other, we dont know how each other sees the game philosophically, and we have a hard time knowing where to draw certain lines.
A few things:
1) my understanding is MA schedules half-crews. Hardly ideal, but at least some small semblance of familiarity. However, I believe even with this arrangement they’re still doing 5-man which is just silly when a ‘state’ championship’s on the line
2) the penalized player put his hand up at the 25 and held it well above his head until the 20 where he saw the BJ flagging him. There’s no sportsmanlike reason for putting your hand that high 25 yards from the end zone, it’s insulting to the other team. Compare that to the LSU punter’s USC: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rRNu_GzdRo4 I think an arm clearly aloft 25 yards out is definitely worse than that momentary spreading of hands. Do you disagree with that comparison? Or would you argue both were wrongly decided? (as I understand it, the LSU USC was just about the first to wipe a TD in FBS play)
3) the MIAA repeatedly, vigorously, and unequivocally emphasized sportsmanship to the teams and officials. I’ve heard the on-site evaluators ‘flipped cartwheels’ over the call. It could very well be MA interprets the rule more strictly than TX (tho you’d never know that from the MIAA’s.
I don’t think the call was perfect, but it wasn’t “bad” either. Did the play scream unsportsmanlike? No. Did the player have ample notice of the strictness of that rule and still choose to draw attention to himself to the denigration of his opponents yet? While I don’t know if I would’ve made that call, I think a sound move would’ve been to wait on the flag another second or two and really let the QB earn it.
“Think of it as the Mike Pereira of HLS.”
Do you WANT us to hate him?
Wouldn’t be the first time, believe me.