Good. Gracious. Lord.
This guy is killing me. Craig Thompson gets an audience with the BCS Overlords and he blows it. COMPLETELY blows it. I’ll give him credit for good intentions, but he gets an F– for his execution.
Whether you want a playoff or you like the current completely f-ed up system, you have to admit this is the wrong way to go about it.
Thompson rolls into town not with a playoff proposal – he rolls in with a presentation that essentially suggests the BCS gets destroyed and they start over. While this is essentially what we’d all like I’d like to happen in the long run, you don’t go in and say that. “Uh, yeah, hi there BCS. What we suggest is that you go die.” How did he expect to accomplish a SINGLE FREAKING THING?
Here’s what he suggested:
- 8 team playoff
- Scrap the entire BCS ranking system – no more computers, no more polls. Replace with a ‘committee’
- Teams 9 and 10 in those rankings play in a ‘BCS Bowl’. (Is this supposed to be the carrot here? 1 lousy bowl with the #’s 9 and 10 teams? Ugh)
- Change revenue sharing (no doubt so that the MWC gets more)
This is so typical of American ‘leaders’. This is an issue that kills deals in business, academics, sports, you name it. It goes something like this:
Thompson to underling ass-kisser: “You know, we have this presentation to the BCS coming up. We need to get a playoff bc the current system isn’t fair to us”
AK: “Agree completely, sir”
T: “While we’re at it, we should ask that they quit operating completely – I mean, those guys don’t want their jobs really, and they don’t make any money, so they shouldn’t mind”
AK: “Great idea, sir! Totally logical to take that extra step”
T: “And really, the MWC should get more money out of the deal – we should essentially get the money the system saves by getting rid of the BCS. That’s only fair.”
AK: “Right on, sir! Shall I give you a foot massage?”
In the end, Thompson got greedy. He figured he’d ask for everything in the hope of getting something. Instead, he’ll get nothing at all.
The BCS sucks. Everyone knows it, including the BCS. The problem is money, and power. So, you have to get a proposal in front of the BCS that does 2 things: 1) Let’s them retain power and 2) Makes them as much, or more, money.
That’s why this is the system that works, at least to get things started with a playoff:
- BCS remains the governing body in charge of the national championship and the ‘big’ post-season bowls
- No, MWC doesnt get more revenue
- BCS polls and Computer ranking system remains in place
- 4-team playoff with the top 4 teams as ranked by the BCS at the end of the season
- 1 vs 4 plays in the first BCS bowl. 2 vs 3 in the second. Winner vs Winner in the National championship BCS bowl. The games rotate to each of the different BCS bowl locations each year.
- The 4th BCS game features traditional picks based on that location’s particular history. (e.g. Rose Bowl gets Big Televen vs USC if they’re not in BCS)
- All other bowls remain as they are – glorified revenue-generating exhibitions with little meaning beyond fun, recruiting and some dollar signs for the networks and the schools, and excellent extension of the CFB season.
This proposal would’ve maybe, POTENTIALLY been actually considered by the BCS. But nooooooooo, Thompson had to go and propose a bunch of crap that muddies the whole thing. 8 teams is too many (just like the English), and it’d take too long. And I know there was a somewhat legit claim by a team ranked outside the Top 4, but you have to cut it off somewhere, and how often will that happen anyway? Shouldn’t be too often. If teams consistently run the gauntlet, they should crawl up into that Top 4 at some point.
You can’t ask the BCS to disband the BCS. And no, the MWC has no bargaining power right now. You’re on the outside looking in buddy! The goal should’ve been to get a playoff considered, not beg for scraps. Ludicrous.
My proposal keeps the BCS in power, should make them more money (with more high-powered matchups), and gets us a playoff with an actual, for-real champion.
Thompson you wasted your time, our time and the BCS’ time, and it’s “efforts” like this that will keep the debate in a quagmire for 20 years before we finally get it done.
This isn’t tough Craig. Understand what they want – see where it intersects with what you want – and go with that.
No wonder the MWC is stuck on the outside looking in.
Share This