Coach Weis, you blew this game for your kids. The streak? Who cares? Means nothing to me.
But there were several "What the F?" decisions made in this game - something I haven't seen in South Bend since Daviengham. Inexplicable decisions that make no sense.
Ball on the 24, 45 seconds left, 4th and 8. You're NOT gonna kick a 41 yard field goal attempt? Really?
Your kids COULD have won the game right there. WOULD they have won? I don't know.
I am sure Coach Weis has info on his kickers that I dont. Maybe they're not that good from 40 or farther. (Okay, first, you need to learn to recruit a kicker if that's the case. But that's another issue.) So let's say he knows the guys aren't good from 40 or further out. Let's say their percentage is 50%. What's your chances on 4th and long? At BEST, 50%. Probably more like 20-30%. So unless those guys are missing 7 out of 10 from that range (which I highly doubt), you kick. And even if they are that bad, it gives you a chance to win the game RIGHT THERE.
We saw progress from our team offensively today (against a POOR Defense, but still), and our kids fought their hearts out. We saw a lot of completely questionable calls from Charlie though. Calls that did not give these kids the best chance to win. Maybe like a FAKE FG on 4th and FIFTEEN when you can take 3 points? What was going ON today?
Coach, it's good that you always take the blame. Because this time, it's definitely on you.
EDIT: Charlie said it was the wind on that end that made him decide to not kick. Our guys were 4 yards short before the game. Still, you kick. 4th and 8? C'mon. And his reasoning for the fake FG was that they had planned it. Okay then Charlie, it was a bad plan. Ugh, I need a freaking 'rita.
By Dneelean November 4, 2007 - 3:15 pm
I go for it on 4th and 8 with 45 seconds left and the game tied all the time. But no one cares if I lose a game on Madden.
Thumbs Up/Down:
0
0
By Mike D. November 4, 2007 - 5:05 pm
Think Barry Alvarez could be enticed to come to ND as AD/coach? Kevin White is as big of a problem as Weis, and he’s got more lives than a cat. Time to show him the door and bring in Alvarez. This thing needs to get totally turned around.
Thumbs Up/Down:
0
0
By JVH November 4, 2007 - 7:08 pm
This one is definitely on Weis.
The whole season is on him. He has been brutal.
The kicker problem is an extension of the biggest problem on the entire team: player development. These players aren’t getting better. We have kickers, they just aren’t taught how to get better at kicking.
Thumbs Up/Down:
0
0
By domer.mq November 4, 2007 - 9:00 pm
“Our kids fought their hearts out” Ha.
No.
Weis should have kicked. It should never, ever have come down to that decision.
Thumbs Up/Down:
0
0